Bobby Bay's

I have to admit, my first visit to Bobby Bay's Sandwich Shop didn’t quite hit the mark for me. For some reason, I wasn’t fond of my sandwich. However, I decided to give them a second chance, and I'm so glad I did! This time, I tried the Big Vito Sandwich, and it was absolutely heavenly. The flavors were incredible, and it completely changed my perception of the place. I love it! BTW, I was going to take a picture of the whole sandwich, but it was so good that I almost ate it all before snapping a shot, lol. If you're in Lancaster, I highly recommend stopping by and trying the Big Vito. You won't be disappointed!

Stopped by Bobby’s while I was in town from St. Louis MO, to give it a chance. And so glad I did. Got the chicken Philly and fries, both Absolutely delicious. Wish there was one near me but I enjoyed it while I can!

I had an Italian the way it comes and was pleasantly surprised. Fresh ingredients, good portions and a rock solid sub! I will definitely return to try the cheese steak. Limited seating and it gets crowded around meal time.

Solid fresh bread, good quality, fresh ingredients, and very reasonable prices for what you're getting. They get the details right, like fresh, bright green (not wilty half yellow) arugula in a sandwich. A good amount of meat, excellent fries served straight from the fryer.

Ordered online and was ready when I got there. Truffle fries and the Johnny Boy. an absolutely amazing sandwich. My new favorite sandwich of anywhere I have been! I can not wait to try the rest of their food because it was so good! Also had the PNP which was a great desert I ate later

One of the top sandwich spots in Lancaster County. I got the Bobby Cheesesteak, which was definitely the best I’ve had in the area and very reminiscent of a good Philly steak. It comes with house whiz, but they also had other options. I went with the cooper sharp. Some spots don’t load the roll enough, but I had plenty of steak, onions and cheese in every bite. A really outstanding sandwich with an amazing roll. You also can’t wrong with the Italian. I was also super shocked at how fast this place is. The wait time was less than five minutes for our sandwiches, even with the place packed. Do yourself a favor and get yourself to Bobby Bay’s.

Currently ranked as my favorite cheesesteak. Love the cherry pepper mayo, love the truffle whiz, love the bread. Yea this is gonna be tough to beat! Oh and the lady at the front was pretty nice and cool =)

I used to say the best sandwich I’ve ever had was at Rosenfeld’s down at the beach, but the Big Vito from Bobby Bay’s is my favorite sandwich of all time. Not even close. I like the cheesesteaks a lot too, but I keep coming back to the BV. I’ve probably had it almost 10 times now. Seriously good. The truffle oil is the move. Their homemade sauces are so good. Always gotta get the cherry pepper mayo and horseradish cream sauce to dip the fries in (fries are also grade-A). I tried Bruno’s the other day after telling a friend about BB. It was good, but the bread and the sauces make BB a league of its own.